Appendix A
Plant Injury and Aillness Rate Tables

Buffalo Stamping Plant (BSP): NAICS 336370 Motor Vehicle Metal Stamping

Year Hours Worked Total # of Cases TCIR # DART Cases DART Rate # LTCR Cases LTCR
2009 1,386,930 95 13.70 23 3.32 11 1.59
2010 1,501,691 102 13.6 17 2.3 11 1.5
2011 1,429,447 92 12.9 19 2.7 16 22
Total 4,318,068 289 59 38
Three Year Rate 2009-2011 13.4 2.77 1.76
BLS National Average for 2010 7.6 3.8

2011-2010 Comparison

  • TCIR: 5% Below
  • DART: 17% Above

2010 BLS Comparison

  • TCIR: 70% Above
  • DART: 29% Below
  • 3 Year TCIR: 76% Above
  • 3 Year DART: 27% Below

Chicago Assembly Plant (CAP): NAICS 336111 Automobile Manufacturing

Year Hours Worked Total # of Cases TCIR # DART Cases DART Rate # LTCR Cases LTCR
2009 2,269,479 134 11.81 35 3.08 14 1.23
2010 3,663,136 232 12.7 35 1.9 16 0.9
2011 6,495,913 298 9.2 70 2.2 29 0.9
Total 12,428,528 664 140 59
Three Year Rate 2009-2011 11.2 2.39 1.01
BLS National Average for 2010 7.7 4.1

2011-2010 Comparison

  • TCIR: 28% Below
  • DART: 16% Above

2010 BLS Comparison

  • TCIR: 19% Above
  • DART: 46% Below
  • 3 Year TCIR: 45% Above
  • 3 Year DART: 42% Below

Chicago Stamping Plant (CSP): NAICS 336370 Motor Vehicle Metal Stamping

Year Hours Worked Total # of Cases TCIR # DART Cases DART Rate # LTCR Cases LTCR
2009 1,460,956 91 12.46 19 2.60 10 1.37
2010 1,626,817 70 8.6 13 1.6 6 0.7
2011 2,082,753 115 11.04 11 1.06 9 0.80
Total 5,170,526 276 43 25
Three Year Rate 2009-2011 10.7 1.75 0.96
BLS National Average for 2010 7.6 3.8

2011-2010 Comparison

  • TCIR: 28% Above
  • DART: 34% Below

2010 BLS Comparison

  • TCIR: 45% Above
  • DART: 58% Below
  • 3 Year TCIR: 41% Above
  • 3 Year DART: 72% Below

Cleveland Engine Plant #1 (CEP1): NAICS 336312 Gasoline Engine and Engine Parts Manufacturing

Year Hours Worked Total # of Cases TCIR # DART Cases DART Rate # LTCR Cases LTCR
2009 564,141 24 8.51 3 1.06 1 0.35
2010 949,053 25 5.3 3 0.6 0 0.0
2011 2,047,784 75 7.32 19 1.86 6 0.59
Total 3,560,978 124 25 7
Three Year Rate 2009-2011 7.04 1.17 0.31
BLS National Average for 2010 5.3 2.7

2011-2010 Comparison

  • TCIR: 28% Above
  • DART: 68% Above

2010 BLS Comparison

  • TCIR: 28% Above
  • DART: 31% Below
  • 3 Year TCIR: 33% Above
  • 3 Year DART: 57% Below

Cleveland Engine Plant #2 (CEP2): NAICS 336312 Gasoline Engine and Engine Parts Manufacturing

Year Hours Worked Total # of Cases TCIR # DART Cases DART Rate # LTCR Cases LTCR
2009 955,040 33 6.91 8 1.68 2 0.42
2010 997,491 46 9.2 15 3.0 4 0.8
2011 968,867 23 4.75 4 0.83 3 0.62
Total 2,921,398 102 27 9
Three Year Rate 2009-2011 6.95 1.28 0.61
BLS National Average for 2010 5.3 2.7

2011-2010 Comparison

  • TCIR: 48% Below
  • DART: 72% Below

2010 BLS Comparison

  • TCIR: 10% Below
  • DART: 69% Below
  • 3 Year TCIR: 31% Above
  • 3 Year DART: 53% Below

Kansas City Assembly Plant (KCAP): NAICS 363111 Automobile Manufacturing

Year Hours Worked Total # of Cases TCIR # DART Cases DART Rate # LTCR Cases LTCR
2009 7,215,408 931 25.81 237 6.57 62 1.72
2010 7,336,073 867 23.6 21.9 6.0 63 1.7
2011 7,740,560 908 23.46 217 5.61 80 2.07
Total 22,292,041 2706 673 205
Three Year Rate 2009-2011 24.29 6.06 1.83
BLS National Average for 2010 7.7 4.1

2011-2010 Comparison

  • TCIR: 0.59% Below
  • DART: 6.5% Below

2010 BLS Comparison

  • TCIR: 205% Above
  • DART: 37% Above
  • 3 Year TCIR: 215% Above
  • 3 Year DART: 48% Above

Lima Engine Plant (LEP): NAICS 336312 Gasoline Engine and Engine Parts Manufacturing

Year Hours Worked Total # of Cases TCIR # DART Cases DART Rate # LTCR Cases LTCR
2009 1,032,686 29 5.62 8 1.55 2 0.39
2010 1,368,933 44 6.4 13 1.9 1 0.1
2011 1,836,733 33 3.59 12 1.31 5 0.54
Total 4,238,352 106 33 8
Three Year Rate 2009-2011 5.20 1.59 0.34
BLS National Average for 2010 5.3 2.7

2011-2010 Comparison

  • TCIR: 44% Below
  • DART: 31% Below

2010 BLS Comparison

  • TCIR: 32% Below
  • DART: 51% Below
  • 3 Year TCIR: 2% Below
  • 3 Year DART: 41% Below

Ohio Assembly Plant (OAP): NAICS 336111 Automobile Manufacturing

Year Hours Worked Total # of Cases TCIR # DART Cases DART Rate # LTCR Cases LTCR
2009 2,514,425 99 7.87 11 0.87 3 0.24
2010 3,081,974 121 7.9 11 0.7 4 0.30
2011 3,308,958 90 5.44 13 0.79 5 0.30
Total 8,905,357 310 35 12
Three Year Rate 2009-2011 7.07 0.79 0.28
BLS National Average for 2010 7.7 4.1

2011-2010 Comparison

  • TCIR: 31% Below
  • DART: 13% Above

2010 BLS Comparison

  • TCIR: 29% Below
  • DART: 81% Below
  • 3 Year TCIR: 8% Below
  • 3 Year DART: 81% Below

Sharonville Transmission Plant (STP): NAICS 336350 Motor Vehicle Transmission and Power Train Parts Manufacturing

Year Hours Worked Total # of Cases TCIR # DART Cases DART Rate # LTCR Cases LTCR
2009 3,147,918 65 4.13 19 1.21 5 0.32
2010 3,588,816 69 3.8 32 1.8 8 0.4
2011 3,545,746 62 3.50 25 1.41 10 0.56
Total 10,282,480 196 76 23
Three Year Rate 2009-2011 3.81 1.47 0.43
BLS National Average for 2010 5.4 2.9

2011-2010 Comparison

  • TCIR: 8% Below
  • DART: 22% Below

2010 BLS Comparison

  • TCIR: 35% Below
  • DART: 51% Below
  • 3 Year TCIR: 29% Below
  • 3 Year DART: 49% Below

Walton Hills Stamping Plant (WHSP): NAICS 336370 Motor Vehicle Metal Stamping

Year Hours Worked Total # of Cases TCIR # DART Cases DART Rate # LTCR Cases LTCR
2009 714,691 25 7.00 0 0.0 0 0.0
2010 790,277 32 8.1 2 0.5 0 0.0
2011 751,685 32 8.51 2 0.53 0 0.0
Total 2,256,653 89 4 0
Three Year Rate 2009-2011 7.87 0.34 0.0
BLS National Average for 2010 7.6 3.8

2011-2010 Comparison

  • TCIR: 5% Above
  • DART: 6% Above

2010 BLS Comparison

  • TCIR: 12% Above
  • DART: 86% Above
  • 3 Year TCIR: 4% Above
  • 3 Year DART: 91% Below

ACH LLC Participating Location (Ohio)

Sandusky Plastics Plant (SPP): NAICS 336399 Other MV Parts Manufacturing

Year Hours Worked Total # of Cases TCIR # DART Cases DART Rate # LTCR Cases LTCR
2009 1,389,398 43 6.19 24 3.45 2 0.29
2010 1,679,957 43 5.1 22 2.6 3 0.1
2011 2,049,237 57 5.56 31 3.03 0 0.0
Total 5,118,592 143 77 5
Three Year Rate 2009-2011 5.62 3.03 0.13
BLS National Average for 2010 5.3 2.9

2011-2010 Comparison

  • TCIR: 9% Above
  • DART: 17% Above

2010 BLS Comparison

  • TCIR: 5% Above
  • DART: 4% Above
  • 3 Year TCIR: 6% Above
  • 3 Year DART: 4% Above

ACH LLC Locations (Michigan)

Saline Plant (SP): NAICS 336111 Automobile Manufacturing

Year Hours Worked Total # of Cases TCIR # DART Cases DART Rate # LTCR Cases LTCR
2009 3,591,581 172 9.58 43 2.39 10 0.56
2010 4,149,038 190 9.16 50 2.41 7 0.34
2011 4,809,306 201 8.36 60 2.50 9 0.37
Total 12,549,925 563 153 26
Three Year Rate 2009-2011 9.03 2.43 0.42
BLS National Average for 2010 7.7 4.1

2011-2010 Comparison

  • TCIR: 9% Below
  • DART: 4% Above

2010 BLS Comparison

  • TCIR: 9% Above
  • DART: 39% Below
  • 3 Year TCIR: 17% Above
  • 3 Year DART: 41% Below

Sheldon Road Plant (SRP): NAICS 336111 Automobile Manufacturing

Year Hours Worked Total # of Cases TCIR # DART Cases DART Rate # LTCR Cases LTCR
2009 1,267,863 126 19.88 27 4.26 4 0.63
2010 1,357,635 139 18.3 32 5.8 11 1.62
2011 1,436,802 114 15.87 22 3.06 1 0.14
Total 4,062,300 379 81 16
Three Year Rate 2009-2011 18.01 4.37 0.80
BLS National Average for 2010 7.7 4.1

2011-2010 Comparison

  • TCIR: 13% Below
  • DART: 47% Below

2010 BLS Comparison

  • TCIR: 106% Above
  • DART: 25% Below
  • 3 Year TCIR: 134% Above
  • 3 Year DART: 7% Above

MIOSHA Participating Sites

Brownstone Parts Redistribution Center (BPRC): NAICS 423120 Motor Vehicle Supplies and New Parts Merchant Wholesalers

Year Hours Worked Total # of Cases TCIR # DART Cases DART Rate # LTCR Cases LTCR
2009 898,696 67 14.91 24 5.34 2 0.45
2010 861,917 60 7.28 18 2.18 5 1.16
2011 885,921 52 11.74 24 5.42 4 0.90
Total 2,646,534 179 66 11
Three Year Rate 2009-2011 11.31 4.31 0.69
BLS National Average for 2010 4.1 2.4

2011-2010 Comparison

  • TCIR: 61% Above
  • DART: 149% Above

2010 BLS Comparison

  • TCIR: 186% Above
  • DART: 126% Above
  • 3 Year TCIR: 176% Above
  • 3 Year DART: 80% Above

Dearborn Diversified Manufacturing Plant/Dearborn Stamping Plant (DDMP/DSP): NAICS 336111 Automobile Manufacturing

Year Hours Worked Total # of Cases TCIR # DART Cases DART Rate # LTCR Cases LTCR
2009 1,564,012 112 14.32 27 3.45 10 1.28
2010 1,703,368 94 11.04 18 2.11 4 0.47
2011 1,852,965 53 5.72 31 3.35 11 1.19
Total 5,120,345 259 76 25
Three Year Rate 2009-2011 10.36 2.97 0.98
BLS National Average for 2010 7.7 4.1

2011-2010 Comparison

  • TCIR: 48% Below
  • DART: 59% Above

2010 BLS Comparison

  • TCIR: 26% Below
  • DART: 18% Below
  • 3 Year TCIR: 35% Above
  • 3 Year DART: 28% Below

Dearborn Engine and Fuel (DEFP): NAICS 336312 Gasoline Engine and Engine Parts Manufacturing

Year Hours Worked Total # of Cases TCIR # DART Cases DART Rate # LTCR Cases LTCR
2009 1,572,579 83 10.56 24 3.05 8 1.02
2010 1,476,311 74 10.02 20 2.71 6 0.81
2011 1,233,695 57 9.24 11 1.78 2 0.32
Total 4,282,585 214 55 16
Three Year Rate 2009-2011 9.94 2.51 0.72
BLS National Average for 2010 5.3 2.7

2011-2010 Comparison

  • TCIR:
  • DART:

2010 BLS Comparison

  • TCIR:
  • DART:
  • 3 Year TCIR:
  • 3 Year DART:

Dearborn Tool & Die (DTDP): NAICS 336370 Motor Vehicle Metal Stamping

Year Hours Worked Total # of Cases TCIR # DART Cases DART Rate # LTCR Cases LTCR
2009 555,080 54 19.46 8 2.88 4 1.44
2010 434,822 32 14.72 7 3.22 2 0.92
2011 556,802 37 13.29 8 2.87 0 0.00
Total 1,546,704 123 23 6
Three Year Rate 2009-2011 15.82 2.99 0.79
BLS National Average for 2010 7.6 3.8

2011-2010 Comparison

  • TCIR: 8% Below
  • DART: 11% Below

2010 BLS Comparison

  • TCIR: 75% Above
  • DART: 25% Below
  • 3 Year TCIR: 108% Above
  • 3 Year DART: 21% Below

Dearborn Truck (DTP): NAICS 336111 Automobile Manufacturing

Year Hours Worked Total # of Cases TCIR # DART Cases DART Rate # LTCR Cases LTCR
2009 4,769,334 738 30.95 176 7.38 55 2.31
2010 5,933,648 870 29.32 176 5.93 42 1.42
2011 6,419,136 957 29.82 228 7.10 85 2.65
Total 17,122,118 2565 580 182
Three Year Rate 2009-2011 30.03 6.80 2.13
BLS National Average for 2010 7.7 4.1

2011-2010 Comparison

  • TCIR: 2% Above
  • DART: 20% Above

2010 BLS Comparison

  • TCIR: 287% Above
  • DART: 73% Above
  • 3 Year TCIR: 290% Above
  • 3 Year DART: 66% Above

Livonia Transmission Plant (LTP): NAICS 336350 Motor Vehicle Transmission and Power Train Parts Manufacturing

Year Hours Worked Total # of Cases TCIR # DART Cases DART Rate # LTCR Cases LTCR
2009 1,880,216 99 10.53 15 1.60 6 0.64
2010 2,201,912 75 6.8 18 1.6 9 0.82
2011 2,153,658 120 11.14 9 0.84 3 0.28
Total 6,235,786 294 42 18
Three Year Rate 2009-2011 9.49 1.35 0.58
BLS National Average for 2010 5.4 2.9

2011-2010 Comparison

  • TCIR: 64% Above
  • DART: 48% Below

2010 BLS Comparison

  • TCIR: 106% Above
  • DART: 71% Below
  • 3 Year TCIR: 76% Above
  • 3 Year DART: 53% Below

Michigan Assembly Plant (MAP): NAICS 336111 Automobile Manufacturing

Year Hours Worked Total # of Cases TCIR # DART Cases DART Rate # LTCR Cases LTCR
2009 4,215,009 225 10.68 41 1.95 12 0.57
2010 5,123,751 227 8.80 47 14.7 14 0.55
2011 7,888,412 280 7.10 72 1.83 28 0.71
Total 17,227,172 732 160 54
Three Year Rate 2009-2011 8.85 6.16 0.61
BLS National Average for 2010 7.7 4.1

2011-2010 Comparison

  • TCIR: 19% Below
  • DART: 88% Below

2010 BLS Comparison

  • TCIR: 8% Below
  • DART: 55% Below
  • 3 Year TCIR: 15% Above
  • 3 Year DART: 50% Above

National Parts Distribution Center (NPDC): NAICS 423120 Motor Vehicle Supplies and New Parts Merchant Wholesalers

Year Hours Worked Total # of Cases TCIR # DART Cases DART Rate # LTCR Cases LTCR
2009 270,902 6 4.43 4 2.95 1 0.74
2010 233,302 15 12.86 9 7.72 0 0.0
2011 225,239 7 6.22 3 2.66 1 0.89
Total 729,443 28 16 2
Three Year Rate 2009-2011 7.84 4.44 0.54
BLS National Average for 2010 4.1 2.4

2011-2010 Comparison

  • TCIR: 52% Below
  • DART: 66% Below

2010 BLS Comparison

  • TCIR: 52% Above
  • DART: 11% Above
  • 3 Year TCIR: 91% Above
  • 3 Year DART: 85% Above

Rawsonville Parts (RP): NAICS 423120 Motor Vehicle Supplies and New Parts Merchant Wholesalers

Year Hours Worked Total # of Cases TCIR # DART Cases DART Rate # LTCR Cases LTCR
2009 1,609,058 72 8.95 22 2.73 4 0.50
2010 1,649,225 60 7.28 18 2.18 4 0.49
2011 1,679,275 47 5.60 18 2.14 4 0.48
Total 4,937,558 179 58 12
Three Year Rate 2009-2011 7.28 2.35 0.49
BLS National Average for 2010 4.1 2.4

2011-2010 Comparison

  • TCIR: 23% Below
  • DART: 2% Below

2010 BLS Comparison

  • TCIR: 37% Above
  • DART: 11% Below
  • 3 Year TCIR: 78% Above
  • 3 Year DART: 2% Below

Romeo Engine Plant (REP): NAICS 336312 Gasoline Engine and Engine Parts Manufacturing

Year Hours Worked Total # of Cases TCIR # DART Cases DART Rate # LTCR Cases LTCR
2009 1,941,559 88 9.06 42 4.33 8 0.82
2010 2,439,716 100 8.20 43 3.53 10 0.82
2011 2,058,269 64 6.22 16 1.55 5 0.49
Total 6,439,544 252 101 23
Three Year Rate 2009-2011 7.83 3.14 0.71
BLS National Average for 2010 5.3 2.7

2011-2010 Comparison

  • TCIR: 24% Below
  • DART: 56% Below

2010 BLS Comparison

  • TCIR: 17% Above
  • DART: 43% Below
  • 3 Year TCIR: 48% Above
  • 3 Year DART: 16% Above

Sterling Transaxle Plant (STAP): NAICS 336350 Motor Vehicle Transmission and Power Train Parts Manufacturing

Year Hours Worked Total # of Cases TCIR # DART Cases DART Rate # LTCR Cases LTCR
2009 3,422,574 212 12.39 80 4.67 25 1.46
2010 3,644,797 227 12.46 76 4.17 22 1.21
2011 3,574,478 193 10.80 86 4.81 42 2.35
Total 10,641,849 632 242 89
Three Year Rate 2009-2011 11.88 4.55 1.67
BLS National Average for 2010 5.4 2.9

2011-2010 Comparison

  • TCIR: 13% Below
  • DART: 15% Above

2010 BLS Comparison

  • TCIR: 100% Above
  • DART: 66% Above
  • 3 Year TCIR: 120% Above
  • 3 Year DART: 57% Above

Vandyke Transmission Plant (VDTP): NAICS 336350 Motor Vehicle Transmission and Power Train parts Manufacturing

Year Hours Worked Total # of Cases TCIR # DART Cases DART Rate # LTCR Cases LTCR
2009 2,582,476 129 9.99 38 2.94 13 1.01
2010 3,032,162 129 8.51 18 1.19 9 0.59
2011 3,225,736 111 6.88 12 0.74 10 0.62
Total 8,840,374 369 68 32
Three Year Rate 2009-2011 8.46 1.62 0.74
BLS National Average for 2010 5.4 2.9

2011-2010 Comparison

  • TCIR: 19% Below
  • DART: 38% Below

2010 BLS Comparison

  • TCIR: 27% Above
  • DART: 74% Below
  • 3 Year TCIR: 57% Above
  • 3 Year DART: 44% Below

Woodhaven Forge Plant (WFP): NAICS 332111 Iron and Steel Forging

Year Hours Worked Total # of Cases TCIR # DART Cases DART Rate # LTCR Cases LTCR
2009 94,789 5 10.55 0 0.0 0 0.0
2010 144,426 3 4.15 0 0.0 0 0.0
2011 190,943 11 11.52 1 1.05 1 1.05
Total 430,158 19 1 1
Three Year Rate 2009-2011 8.74 0.35 0.35
BLS National Average for 2010 9.2 4.8

2011-2010 Comparison

  • TCIR: 178% Above
  • DART: 100% Above

2010 BLS Comparison

  • TCIR: 20% Above
  • DART: 78% Below
  • 3 Year TCIR: 5% Below
  • 3 Year DART: 93% Below

Woodhaven Stamping Plant (WSP): NAICS 336370 Motor Vehicle Metal Stamping

Year Hours Worked Total # of Cases TCIR # DART Cases DART Rate # LTCR Cases LTCR
2009 1,787,019 129 14.44 25 2.80 5 0.56
2010 1,842,179 120 13.03 28 3.04 9 0.98
2011 2,052,488 108 10.52 16 1.56 7 0.68
Total 5,681,686 357 69 21
Three Year Rate 2009-2011 12.66 2.47 0.74
BLS National Average for 2010 7.6 3.8

2011-2010 Comparison

  • TCIR: 19% Below
  • DART: 49% Below

2010 BLS Comparison

  • TCIR: 38% Above
  • DART: 59% Below
  • 3 Year TCIR: 67% Above
  • 3 Year DART: 35% Below